Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Categories
In this Discussion
Top Posters
- Arkady 5356
- miss annie 5139
- andy 4506
- Ali 3405
- krappyrubsnif 3208
- tosscat 2291
- David 2179
- ADGS 1875
- kreuzkav 1733
- Mirandola 1618
Gravational analogy
While I know it to be true that objects of different weights fall to earth at the same rate of acceleration I can't quite believe it. I look at Newton's numbers and explanations but then just as I'm starting to believe a picture of Wiley Coyote strapped to a boulder falling down the side of a mountain comes to mind and its all over.
Aristotle had this problem too I believe. Can someone give me a layman's analogy please.
Comments
A second experiment for both yourself and Dion is to take a rolled up sock and a very light receipt and drop them from the same height (I did about a meter). You will see the sock hits the ground much faster. This is because the drag is considerably less on the sock.
The rate of acceleration of gravity is 9.81m/s/s but drag must also be taken into account which will cause less aerodynamic objects to have lower terminal velocities and to reach them slower.
I believe the peregrine falcon has one of the fastest falls when it swoops to get it's prey, this is due to it being so aerodynamic.
But you probably know that already.
One way to think of it is to think of the larger object as being composed of two small objects stuck together. Both the 'small' objects will fall at the same speed and hence at the same speed as the 'large' object. Now think of separating the large object into two REAL small obejcts but leave them separated by only a tiny distance. Do you think they'd suddenly start falling more slowly? How far apart would they have to be in order for you to consider them as two objects?
This now brings up the far more important questions:
Do Cartoon characters need to breath???
If not then no atmosphere makes everything fall at the same speed. But then we would lose all those big explosions...
Take tom and jerry and blindfold jerry, then get tom to chase jerry over a chasm. Jerry will happily run right over the chasm to the other side, because he cannot see the fall. Tom will follow jerry and then, after a few yards, he will see that he is running on thin air and plummet to another amusing catastrophe.
But you probably know that already.
A second experiment is to send Tom and Jerry into space and give a space suit to _Tom_. Both will be fine initially, Tom because he has a space suit and Jerry because he does not realise that he needs to breath. But as soon as Jerry pulls tom's face mask off, Tom will realise that he has no oxygen and choke dramatically as Jerry looks on nonchalantly.
I wonder if you can explain another problem because I read a few years ago that there's some doubt on this theory; that heavier objects do, in fact, hit the ground first on scale that's measurable only at a sub-atomic level. OK, so it's a percentage that's almost impossible to measure with current technology, but can this be true, I wonder? I got confused when it then said that depending on whether the falling object was terrestrial or extra-terrestrial in origin, the lighter object could hit the ground first. Eh? What the fuck's that all about? And that some objects bend space around themselves or pull the earth towards them...? AAAAAGH! I think it was New Scientist wot told me.
Either that or I was drunk, watching Star Trek.
Anyway, whatever the case, blood started coming out of my ears at this point, but I'd be grateful for someone clever than me explaining it.
|f| = {G M_A M_B \over |r_{AB}|^2} (copied from Wiki)
Where G is the gravitational constant x Mass A x Mass B
Over
Distance between A and B squared
I'm not sure if that could account for it. I think this may only be effectual with large masses. And I'm not sure why that would only be on a sub atomic level.
I'm going to cower behind my chair as this is destroyed by someone with more physics understanding than I as I haven't studied it for years...